A homeless man has sparked a heated conversation online after reportedly turning down money offered to him by well-known South African philanthropist BI Phakathi.
The unexpected encounter has attracted attention because, instead of accepting the cash, the man explained that he preferred to rely on his own efforts to make a living. His response has since prompted social media users to debate the meaning of dignity, independence and accepting help.
BI Phakathi is widely known for his acts of kindness, particularly towards people experiencing poverty and homelessness. His videos often show him approaching people in difficult circumstances and offering them money, food or other forms of assistance.
In many of these encounters, recipients become emotional after receiving unexpected support. However, this particular interaction took a very different turn when the homeless man declined the financial assistance.
According to the account shared online, the man explained that he had a trolley and earned money by pushing it. He reportedly told BI Phakathi in Sesotho, “Ha ke batle chelete ea hao. Ke na le trolley. Ke push trolley,” meaning that he did not want his money because he had a trolley and worked by pushing it.
His response appeared to surprise the philanthropist and those who watched the encounter.
The man’s decision has led to contrasting reactions on social media. Some people questioned why someone experiencing homelessness would reject an opportunity to receive money, arguing that any assistance could make his difficult circumstances slightly easier.
Others, however, praised him for wanting to depend on his own labour. They said his response demonstrated that being poor or homeless does not necessarily mean a person has abandoned their sense of pride or independence.
For many viewers, the moment raised a broader question about how society views people living on the streets. Poverty can often lead people to assume that those struggling financially will automatically accept whatever assistance is offered to them.
However, the man’s refusal demonstrated that people experiencing hardship still have choices and personal boundaries.
His reliance on a trolley to earn money also highlighted the lengths some people go to in order to survive. While his circumstances may be challenging, he appeared determined to continue working rather than simply accepting a handout.
The encounter also encouraged conversations about the nature of charitable giving. Helping someone in need can be meaningful, but assistance does not necessarily have to come in the form of money. Some people may prefer employment opportunities, food, clothing or support that allows them to become more financially independent.
Ultimately, the viral moment has resonated because it presented a different side of homelessness. Rather than simply being portrayed as someone waiting for assistance, the man presented himself as someone who was still trying to earn a living.
His decision may not be understood by everyone, but it served as a reminder that dignity can mean different things to different people. For this man, independence appeared to matter more than receiving unexpected cash.
The encounter has therefore become more than a simple exchange between a philanthropist and a person in need. It has sparked an important conversation about charity, self-respect and the right of every individual to decide what kind of assistance they are willing to accept.
About the Author
